<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src="https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=456359911403087&amp;ev=PageView&amp;noscript=1">
HELOC vs Home Equity Loan Which is Best for Debt Consolidation Blog Feature

By: America's Credit Union on June 17th, 2022

Print/Save as PDF

HELOC vs Home Equity Loan Which is Best for Debt Consolidation

Personal Finance | Home & Mortgage Tips | Home and Mortgage

If you want to save money and make some progress in paying off the bills and other debt you owe, you should consider accessing the equity in your home for a debt consolidation loan to achieve your goal of being debt-free.

The two typical ways to access the equity in your home for a debt consolidation loan include a home equity loan and a home
equity line of credit, better known as a HELOC. Below are some comparisons of a HELOC vs Home Equity Loan so you can see the pros and cons of each.

What's the Difference Between a Home Equity Loan and a HELOC?

While both types of loans have some similarities, such as the fact that both are based on the available equity in your home, there are some big differences between a HELOC vs home equity loan. If you are considering either type of loan that utilizes the equity in your home, you first need to find the amount of equity in your home, which can be done by finding the current value minus the balance of the loan you still owe.

  • Home Equity Loans – A home equity loan is a type of loan available at your credit union that offers a fixed interest rate and set monthly payment for the money you borrow. Typically referred to as a second mortgage, once the home equity loan is approved, you receive a lump sum of money to spend however you wish.

  • HELOC – A home equity line of credit is an approved revolving credit line of credit that allows you to borrow or draw money as needed and pay it back over time via monthly installments. The HELOC is similar to a credit card, as the interest rate is variable, but it does offer a substantially lower interest rate and a credit limit that is based on the equity of your home.

The main difference between a HELOC vs home equity loan is that home equity loans have a set interest rate, whereas HELOCs typically have adjustable interest rates, like credit cards.



Is a Home Equity Loan or HELOC Better for Debt Consolidation?

While trying to determine the advantages of a HELOC vs home equity loan for your financial situation, there are some things to consider. Weigh the differences between the two types of loans to see the pros and cons so that you can make an educated decision based on your situation and financial goals.




Pros and Cons - HELOC vs Home Equity Loan

Pros of Home Equity Loans

  • Simplified finances with just one payment a month
  • Predetermined payoff date versus open-ended interest-driven balance
  • Lower monthly payment

Cons of Home Equity Loans

  • Tax deductibility is restricted to building and home renovations of homes
  • The in-depth loan process with home appraisal and income verification
  • Loan costs can add up when you factor in lender fees, closing costs like appraisals, etc.

Pros of HELOC

  • Lower interest rate than credit cards
  • Securing a HELOC now ensues access to funds should you need them later in an emergency
  • Easy access to your money versus accessing retirement counts that have penalties

Cons of HELOC

  • If market conditions change, your house may lose value
  • Possible foreclosure
  • Risk of more debt



Learn More About the Pros and Cons of a HELOC vs Home Equity Loan

While both types of loans offer a variety of advantages, as expected, there are a few downsides as well, as there are with any type of loan. Here are the pros and cons of getting a HELOC vs Home Equity Loan for debt consolidation.



More About the Pros of Home Equity Loans


  • Single Payment Each Month – Keeping track of car payments, medical bills, and credit card debt, each month is a challenge. When you consolidate your debt, you can reduce that to just a single payment per month, making your bill-paying regime simple.
  • Pay Off in Sight – A home equity loan offers a set interest rate over a predetermined amount of time, so you can see your financial goals clearly in sight.
  • Lower Your Payment – Your set loan terms with lower interest rates also equals a lower monthly payment which gives you extra money each month that enables you to pay off your debt faster.



More About the Cons of Home Equity Loans


  • Can You Deduct That? - Recent changes to tax laws now limit the deductibility of home equity loans. The new law restricts the deduction of the loan interest to include only the part of the loan money that was used for building and home renovations of the property.
  • Time Consuming Loan Process – Unlike applying for a personal loan or credit card, applying for a home equity loan requires an in-depth loan process which often includes a home appraisal, bank statements, tax returns, W-2s, and other typical financial loan documents. In addition, the process can take up to 30 days to gain access to the funds.
  • Loan Costs – A home equity loan comes with some fees that you may not be aware of. There are typically closing costs that can include lender fees and appraisals that you are required to pay to get the loan.



To discover how a home equity loan can help you achieve your goals, download our free eBook: 

The Complete Home Equity Loan Guide: All You Need to Know



More About the Pros of a HELOC

  • Lower Interest Rates - Homeowners get better loan rates when they borrow against the equity in their homes. Since the debt is secured with your property, HELOCs offer significantly lower interest rates than most credit cards.
  • Easy Access to Funds - Securing a HELOC now ensures access to funds should you need them later. The HELOC will be easily accessible via a check or debit card for your use for major purchases, home improvement, or in the event of an emergency.
  • No Penalties – A HELOC lets you access your money when you need it without paying early withdrawal fees or penalties like accounts like your retirement or 401k accounts.



More About the Cons of a HELOC


  • Change in Market Conditions - If the real estate market conditions in your area change, your property may lose value. If this happens, it means that you might end up owing more on the house than it is worth, making it more difficult to sell.
  • Possible Foreclosure – A HELOC uses your house as the collateral for the loan, meaning that while you get the benefit of much lower interest rates on the loan, it also presents a greater risk, which is losing the property if you fail to repay the loan as required.
  • Risk of More Debt – Sometimes when homeowners obtain a HELOC, they make excessive purchases due to the attractive lower interest rate they are offered. This can end up burdening the homeowner with more debt than they started with, which is not a good situation, so it is crucial to be careful of the debt you collect.


America’s Credit Union offers affordable home equity loans, personal loans, and low rate credit cards to help with your debt consolidation needs. If you are ready, visit our website and apply online.

Still not sure which solution is right for you? Contact our loan professionals today to review your specific financial situation and find the best product for your needs.


To discover more differences between a HELOC vs home equity loan, review  "The Complete Home Equity Loan Guide: All You Need to Know" eBook.


Membership in America’s Credit Union is open to anyone who lives or works in Dallas, Rockwall or Collin Counties, Texas, and their family members. Employees of select employers may also be eligible. See our Membership page for details.

Sort Blogs by Category